When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Pair of original pen-and-ink political cartoon drawings signed W. Thorndike, depicting President William McKinley, prominent Republican political figures, and controversies surrounding the Spanish-American War.
Dating to approximately 1899–1900, these large original editorial illustrations offer a remarkable look at American political satire during the closing years of the 19th century.
Both drawings are original artwork rather than printed newspaper cartoons. They retain handwritten captions, editorial production markings, and identifying numbers associated with their preparation for newspaper reproduction.
Drawing No. 270 – “Stop Knocking the General”
Measures approximately 26.75 x 21 inches.
This political cartoon addresses General Nelson A. Miles and the controversy surrounding the United States Army following the Spanish-American War of 1898.
Miles is depicted sawing wood, with imagery referencing the Army beef scandal, a major controversy involving the quality of meat supplied to American soldiers during the war.
The handwritten caption reads:
“Stop knocking the General. He isn’t saying a word but just sawing wood.”
The drawing reflects the political tensions surrounding military leadership, public criticism, and the McKinley administration during the aftermath of the war.
Drawing No. 285 – “McKinley’s Marionettes”
Measures approximately 26.5 x 19 inches.
This elaborate political cartoon depicts a theatrical puppet show titled “McKinley’s Marionettes.”
President William McKinley and Republican political leader Mark Hanna appear above the stage, manipulating marionettes representing prominent government and military figures.
Identifiable names include:
* Russell A. Alger – Secretary of War
* Henry C. Corbin – Adjutant General of the U.S. Army
* William R. Shafter – U.S. Army general
* Charles P. Eagan – Commissary General of Subsistence
The stage bears the inscription “Season of 1896–1900,” referencing McKinley’s presidential administration and the political influence surrounding it.
The illustration offers a pointed contemporary criticism of political control, military appointments, and the relationship between government leadership and the armed forces.
About the Artist – W. Thorndike
The drawings are signed W. Thorndike and attributed to Willis Hale Thorndike (1872–1940), an American illustrator and political cartoonist associated with newspaper illustration during the late 19th and early 20th centuries.
Thorndike studied art in the United States and Europe, including at the Art Students League of New York and the Académie Julian in Paris.
His career included work associated with the San Francisco Chronicle, New York Herald, and Baltimore American.
Political cartoonists of this period produced original pen-and-ink illustrations that were photographically reduced for publication in newspapers. These drawings preserve the original artwork rather than the much smaller printed versions encountered by newspaper readers.
Original Newspaper Production Details
One drawing retains the handwritten notation “4 cols daily,” indicating preparation for reproduction at approximately four newspaper columns in width.
The drawings are individually numbered 270 and 285.
These production markings, together with the handwritten captions and signatures, provide additional evidence of their intended use as newspaper editorial illustrations.
The original newspaper publication and exact printing dates have not been established.
Measurements
* Drawing No. 270: Approximately 26.75 x 21 inches
* Drawing No. 285: Approximately 26.5 x 19 inches
* Medium: Original pen-and-ink drawings on paper
* Artist: Signed W. Thorndike
* Period: Circa 1899–1900
* Quantity: Two original drawings, sold together
Condition
Both drawings show age-related toning, creasing, edge wear, tears, and small paper losses consistent with their age and history as working editorial artwork.
Please examine all photographs carefully for the condition of each drawing, including the paper edges, original signatures, handwritten captions, and production markings.
Offered together as a pair of original American political cartoons documenting the William McKinley administration, Spanish-American War, Army beef scandal, and political controversies of the Gilded Age.
An important pair for collectors of original political cartoon art, American newspaper illustration, presidential history, Spanish-American War memorabilia, and 19th-century American political ephemera.
